Ref was doing a good job Dem, then there was a particularly hefty tackle on a French player who ended up coming down about 150 degrees rotated and landed on his shoulders, instantly there was a but of 'argie-bargee' between the two packs and the reff snapped to a decission of a red card, no consulting with the linesmen or 4th official... Reds are VERY rare in rugby and at this level of game given what was at stake he should have considered others opinoins before such an award.... Yellow & 10 minutes in the sin bin would have been apropriate; no malice intended in the tackle.