What is going on with that suspension - so high?
View attachment 108420
I've driven both. As everyone says, the MC Shift/Strad is the one to get if you want character. I'd only get the auto if I was doing daily city/town driving in slow traffic. Also, the auto is higher geared so cruises at lower revs on the motorway.
Regarding carbon ceramics, don't believe the Internet! They are not as fragile as everyone makes out and it's pretty easy to spot ones that have been mistreated. In normal road driving, you'll have 50k+ without changing pads and 100k+ without changing discs. Also, the discs don't rust and no brake dust.